I teamed up with Kalena’s Kitchen for an in depth tasting of various gins.
Contenders:
Seagrams Extra Dry Gin
Bombay Saphire
Beefeater
Tanqueray
Death’s Door
We compared our own tasting notes to that of each companies:
Seagrams: Them: Light bodied, sweetish, earthy.
US: Nose: Absolute grapefruit bomb. Single note. Sharp. Taste: Grapefruit, pepper, light bodied, smooth, quick nice cooling at the end.
Conclusion: Decently distilled, would work best in a mixed drink, perhaps one with a tropical emphasis as the grapefruit is overwhelming in this gin.
Bombay Saphire: Them: Light bodied, citrusy, sweet.
US: Nose: No sharpness, a bouquet of many unfamiliar pleasant aromoas. Taste: Hint of pine, much like the nose, tastes like a bouquet of herbs. So many different hints and flavors but none that stood out as very familiar. Well balanced, no single note over powered the others. Very well balanced. Light bodied.
Conclusion: This was the most versatile gin we tasted. Could be prepared as a martini, and would also be great in any mixed gin beverage.
Beeferater: Them: light bodied, impeccably clean, floral, pine tree.
US: Nose: Juniper dominant. Taste: Straight foreword gin. Clean, crisp, dry finish. No bells and whistles. A gin drinker’s gin.
Conclusion: Do not order this gin if you are not much of a gin drinker. There are no pretty notes and flavors, its very straightforward. It’s quality is good enough to be served on it’s own or mixed.
Tanqueray: Them: Full bodied, fruity, oily, dry, juniper dominant.
US: Nose: Juniper bomb. Taste: Juniper dominant, very rich and oily. Went down hot and failed to cool on the finish.
Conclusion: Because this gin is very full bodied, oily and juniper dominant, we agree it would best be served with a fizzy/acidic mixture. Would make a great classic gin+tonic because the flavor of the gin would not be over powered by the tonic.
Deaths Door: This is a small batch gin from a craft distillery in WI. I invested in this bottle because I really wanted to see how a craft gin would hold up against the more popular/well known gins. Needless to say, this gin kicked butt. It was the absolute most interesting, delicious, dynamic and fun gin we have ever tried.
Them: Pine, Corriander, fennel.
US: Nose: Ice cold Wisconsin forrest. Very pine foreword but a wintery pine. Taste: Bursting with flavor. Unlike the nose, the pine taste did not over shadow the coriander. Bittersweet orange rind. Incredibly smooth to swallow, all the way down. A hint of heat afterwards which cooled off. No alcohol burn whatsoever.
Conclusion: This was our winner. Dynamic, interesting, artfully crafted. Should be enjoyed AS IS. Such a special gin that adding anything to it would be a waste. A new take on gin, recommended for all the huge gin fans out there!